Has Digital Art Finally Made It? A Conversation with Nadim Samman

The Overview spoke with Samman ahead of Loop Festival in Barcelona about the origins of the label “digital art,” the ecological cost of AI spectacle and the uneasy relationship between museums and technology companies.

Has Digital Art Finally Made It? A Conversation with Nadim Samman
Nadim Samman, director of Autotelic Foundation, speaking on the panel “In the Fold: Has Digital Art Finally Made It?” at Loop Talks, Barcelona, 2026. Photo: LOOP

“Has digital art finally made it?” That was the question on the table this Thursday at Loop Talks in Barcelona. Moderated by curator and technologist Ben Vickers, the panel featured leading voices in digital culture, among them Sabine Himmelsbach of HeK, curator Polly Staple, José Luis de Vicente, founder of Sónar+D, and Nadim Samman, director of Autotelic Foundation, which fosters creation and debate at the intersection of art and technology. 

The central discussion circled around the usefulness of digital art as a separate category. José Luis de Vicente called this question a “Freudian compulsion”, “a kind of collective trauma”, that the community has tried to overcome for more than 30 years. “We cannot define what digital art is or whether it means anything anymore. In a strict sense, all music in the world today is electronic music because it’s all recorded in digital workstations. It is edited to the max. It is all processed through digital effects. So there’s only electronic music.” 

He then pointed out the confusion between a medium-specific or a methodology-specific context of artistic practice. The latter refers to experimental, research-based, process-driven ways of working, for example with networks or unstable systems. In that sense, a separate category might still be useful. “There is a field of exploration that overflows both categories and institutional frameworks of what the art world does.”

To him work that calls itself art can do far more than an exhibition allows. It can exist in more places and take more forms than a museum can host, and more than the traditional role of “the artist” covers. To him art can exist in labs, as tools and in companies. 

To Sabine Himmelsbach, specialised institutions like HeK still play a vital role as they preserve the history of artworks made with technology and educate the public on complex creations that are often overlooked. 

To Nadim Samman, the label digital art can help and hinder at the same time. As an example he named Zero 10 at Art Basel, which he called “a kind of gilded ghetto.” He compared it to the survey shows of Chinese contemporary art in the early 2000s ahead of the Olympics: these categories introduced new positions to the wider art world, but they also boxed artists in. “Like  Kafka says, it's a cage looking for a bird, but it's a golden cage.”

The Overview spoke with Samman ahead of Loop about the origins of the label “digital art,” the ecological cost of AI spectacle and the uneasy relationship between museums and technology companies.

The Overview: How do you see the relationship between digital art and media art?

Nadim Samman: I think digital art is an evolution of media art. Both terms designate artistic practices by the medium or techniques employed, which can be useful for painting with broad brushstrokes. But we live in a time of intermedia and interdisciplinarity in the art world. 

There's a general understanding that crossing media boundaries is part and parcel of being an artist today. The term media art was established some decades ago, and it was useful in defining a new space for artistic practice outside traditional forms like painting or sculpture.

Now we've entered a time in which the stigma associated with non-traditional artistic media has disappeared. It's important to throw away the crutches and understand that digital art has a place within what we might more broadly call contemporary art.

This is important because the world has changed and everyone relies on digital technologies to have a contemporary experience. If we talk about contemporary art, art made with digital technology is front and center.

Some voices in the community worry that as digital art becomes more established within the traditional art world, it could be absorbed and lose its distinctive identity, its independence or innovative edge. What’s your take on this?

Nadim Samman: I'm not sure about that. I think digital art loses its identity and independence when it's packaged too tightly as digital art. Think about the NFT boom. There was a strong push from vested interests outside the traditional art market. Crypto entrepreneurs tried to bring a digital ownership product into the art world, and auction houses like Sotheby's and Christie's got on board. But, as we saw from what happened with NFTs, the movement lacked a certain credibility because it was so tightly connected to crypto as a project. It didn't feel organic.

Artists had been making work using VR technologies and 3D generation software for a long time. All of that was already in galleries, museums and biennales, perhaps to a lesser degree than other art forms, but it was already accepted.

What's difficult is to brand digital art as a separate space and make it special, while acknowledging that digital technology is ubiquitous. There's a tension between these two ways of looking at it, but both are part of the same wave of digitization sweeping across society and into every area of our lives. That's why I argue that we should cancel that distinction.

On the other hand, the term is still useful if we define it by subject rather than medium. Digital art would then be art that explores, interrogates and narrates the digital through artistic practice.

If digital art is defined by its subject rather than its medium, where does that leave immersive experiences, like Van Gogh projection shows? Do they belong in museums?

Nadim Samman: Immersive experiences are part of an experience economy and at the same time they belong to the broader art world. The question is: are they interesting? Popular art exists everywhere, but that doesn't mean much of it repays deep attention. It depends on why someone visits a museum. Is it to have an overwhelming sensory experience that might lack a critical dimension? I think the history of art in the modern period suggests otherwise. But you also can’t necessarily rule out these forms of presentation in museums. I don't think it's wrong to include them, although immersive digital experiences might not match up with the more intellectually rigorous works in the collection.

One of the most prominent representatives of immersive installations is Refik Anadol. His work is often described as spectacle, but he also tries to introduce a philosophical perspective on how machines perceive human culture and the natural world. Can spectacle and depth go hand in hand?

Nadim Samman: I think the reason his work is shown so often is that not many other people are able to create such an intensity of spectacle using AI tools. The Dataland Museum he co-founded proposes to offer an experience of nature in a remixed way, and this is where I get uneasy.

The idea of creating a spectacular simulacrum of nature using creative technology is a little unsettling, because these AI tools have a massive ecological footprint. The copper and rare earth elements used in cables and chips are mined, and the energy and resources required to create this hardware are enormous. The data centers powering AI also need large amounts of electricity and water.

These technologies are therefore running against an ecological agenda. If the idea is to enter a space and feel that all this technology is being used to connect the visitor more deeply with an impression of nature, yet that impression is entirely simulated and built on top of an abuse of natural resources, then I think we enter a space that is counterproductive. If this is how we want to see nature in museums, I would disagree.

Every artist who engages with technology also depends on its tools. Technology affects every aspect of our lives, so it might be difficult to criticize it independently. How do you see that entanglement?

Nadim Samman: You're right that it's complicated to establish a critical position within that entanglement. But I think the key is honesty about that entanglement in the work and this is where the example we've just been exploring, the simulation of a natural environment by someone like Refik Anadol, falls short. That self-critical position isn't present in the art. I don't subscribe to the view that if you have a critical perspective on tech, you shouldn't use any. That’s like saying if I don’t like fossil fuels, I should leave the city and live off-grid. Some people do think that, but it’s a very hard ask, and I don’t believe anyone should feel guilty if they can’t escape what they critique. What I want from art is a space to reflect on not just who I am, but who I want to become.

Today, technology companies also serve as patrons of the arts and are involved in museums in different ways, often through brand partnerships. Some technology CEOs also hold positions on the boards of these institutions. How do you balance that entanglement when you depend on the money?

Nadim Samman: Museums wouldn't be pushed into the hands of private sponsors if they were better funded by governments. If we live in a society that is well taxed and where culture is a public good, underfunding it is a mistake. When you look for sponsorship as an institution, of course you go where the money is. And the best-funded companies in the world are now tech and AI companies. There are trillions of dollars in this sector. 

At the very least, the artist and the institution should set the agenda before a tech company comes on board, rather than a corporation proposing, "We've built this shiny new tool and we're making resources available if you'll use it to make art." That's the wrong way around.

Which artists working with technology are you currently following?

Nadim Samman: I think Holly Herndon, Mat Dryhurst and Trevor Paglen are interesting. They're well-known names, and what makes their work compelling is how they look at systems, for example how generative AI systems are trained. They give you an exploded view of the technology and, in doing so, often critique the ways it has been used in society. By showing you how it’s put together, they can point to where its use might be inappropriate or fall short in certain contexts.

You can also look at Kate Crawford and Vladan Joler. They're mapping all the spaces around an AI system, from politics and economics to ecology and the history of technology. This widens the frame, and that's the point.

The danger is to be inside an immersive digital environment that seems to show us everything, but actually we are stuck in a box. We don't see the back end or the compromises. We need an expanded view of these technologies.

Are there also artists you find compelling who don't necessarily engage critically with technology?

Nadim Samman: I think Lu Yang is a very deep artist. Their video work explores their own vision of Buddhist cosmology and metaphysics. The videos feature various avatars of Lu Yang, including one called Doku, which goes on a journey through different states of being that are outlined in Buddhist scriptures, classical and sometimes contemporary: different levels of consciousness or metaphysical experiences, including hell and heaven.

The visualization of these far-out images from the Buddhist religious imaginary would be very difficult to achieve using other techniques. It's been tried, but Lu Yang is really updating the idea of a Buddhist visual imaginary for the contemporary moment and the result is an extremely rich, complex world that builds out an ancient tradition into the contemporary space. I find that fascinating, and it's visually compelling.

The spectacle of their videos is also a critique of visuality. Buddhists believe that this world is all appearance, and that we have to meditate, transcend and pierce the veil of images to reach a higher truth.

Lu Yang’s videos are deliberately over the top and there's something empty about this spectacle. Paradoxically, they're throwing all the bells and whistles at the viewer to suggest that images matter less than we think. It's a wonderful way of turning things around, playing with the seduction of spectacle while talking about its emptiness.


Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to The Overview.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.